by Jared Newman
What’s this? A place for posts that might be too fleeting, esoteric, or off-topic for the weekly Advisorator newsletter. A little slice of the independent web. A work in progress. Subscribe via RSS if you want.
-
It’s getting harder to sell a newsletter
Natalie Jarvey for The Ankler:
“Newsletters are cooked,” says Taylor Lorenz, whose own User Mag newsletter boasts 97,000 total subscribers. Two years ago, Lorenz left her high-profile job as a columnist at The Washington Post for what she described then as the “complete autonomy” of reaching her audience directly in their email inboxes. But she says she’s lost a third of her paid subscribers in the past several months, and she predicts an AI-driven extinction event. “I don’t think we’re going to be reading email newsletters in five years,” Lorenz says.
Things aren’t quite so dire with my humble tech advice newsletter, but I’m feeling the trend as my paid subscriber count has been more or less in the same place since the beginning of the year. While I’m not losing people much faster than before, new subscribers are definitely harder to come by, and sale events don’t have the juice that they used to. I think it’s a combination of email fatigue, subscription fatigue, and the economy.
The bigger concern is that free sign-ups seem to be slowing down, particularly on the Cord Cutter Weekly side. That’s where AI is the real problem: Google and ChatGPT steal what I write, and people don’t click links anymore.
Fundamentally, though, I’m optimistic that a lot of people still enjoy attaining knowledge through reading human writing, even if it’s not the majority. The challenge will be to keep finding those people as they are increasingly overwhelmed by noise.
-
USB switcher died after four years. This time I'm treating myself to one with a remote clicker, which costs $3 extra.
-
Holding off on an iPhone Duo
I’m a big foldable phone fan and thought about selling off a bunch of other Apple gear—M4 iPad Pro, 6th-gen iPad Mini, maybe even my regular iPhone 16 Pro Max—to get an iPhone Duo.
But now the reviews are here, and the verdict is mixed. While pretty much everyone loves the ability to conjure an iPad Mini from their pockets, the passport shape is awkward to hold when closed and makes one-handed use difficult. I already knew this from my time with Samsung’s Galaxy Z Fold8, but the Duo’s added weight and thickness exacerbates the problem. The old adage with new Apple product categories is that you always wait for the second generation, and as The Verge’s review argues, this is the messiest first-generation Apple product in some time. Too bad, because some of the early iPhone Duo apps look delightful.
It’s odd how quickly consensus formed around the passport shape being the ideal foldable format, only for reviewers to then knock it. I don’t expect Apple to release a taller foldable akin to Samsung’s Fold8 Ultra (which is still what I prefer), but hopefully future iterations will feel a little less compromised (and, perhaps, less prone to screen damage).
-
What’s wrong with Mastodon?
Matt Birchler (via Michael Tsai):
Forget everything about how other social networks are bad, what makes it so that almost everyone who joins Mastodon gives up on it? I don’t have easy answers (although I have some ideas, maybe for another post), I mostly wanted to write this to get my fellow Mastodon users thinking. Are we happy being an ever-shrinking niche social network? If we are, then how can we be mad at everyone who chooses to use something else? If we aren’t, then how can we make this place something more people want to spend time on?
Like Birchler, I like Mastodon and just resolved to spend more time there.
But content is king. Mastodon caters to a handful of niches. It’s not a place to go for sports, pop culture, or politics beyond a narrow subset. Part of that is inherent to the setup of a federated social network, but even Bluesky, whose interface and sign-up flow is considerably nicer than Mastodon’s, feels constrained in the kinds of posts that show up there. X (and to a lesser extent Threads) can leverage their existing audiences to supply content in ways that Mastodon cannot.
I don’t have the answers, but I really like the idea of building small but enduring internet communities outside the domain of tech giants, which are hollowing out the broader internet as we know it. So I’m just going to keep posting/reacting/commenting and hoping the connections follow.
-
Impulse-bought an M-VAVE FM-1 after reading about all the community-made firmware available for it.
Turns out there’s a site where you can play around with virtual firmware in a browser before installing: https://amacias.github.io/octo-vave/

This is going to be a lot of fun.
-
Bringing back the Advisorator blog
The story thus far:
- I tried spinning up a “Blog” section of Advisorator for stuff that doesn’t fit into the newsletter.
- Then I decided I should just blog on my jarednewman.com domain instead.
- Inevitably I let the personal blogging fall by the wayside.
I think what I’m going to do is let jarednewman.com operate as more of a portfolio/bio site, and revive the Advisorator blog for posting. A few reasons why:
- Posting about tech-related things (which is a lot of what I might want to post about) felt out of place on my personal site.
- I’ve realized it’s not really a bad thing to have off-topic stuff on the Advisorator site, as long as it’s out of the way of the usual tech coverage.
- Maybe there’s a little extra motivation to post here if it leads folks to discover the newsletter.
I’m going to see how this goes, and maybe add a “Blog” heading to the nav bar if the habit sticks. Also: I’m writing and publishing this directly from Obsidian with a plugin, which I haven’t done in a while. Let’s see if it works.
-
Affiliate links in Advisorator
For the past eight-ish years, I’ve taken a hard stance against affiliate links in Advisorator.
Affiliate links allow writers, YouTubers, and other content creators to earn sales commissions from the products and services they cover. If a website posts about deal on a portable charger, for instance, an affiliate link provides that site with a cut of any resulting sales.
I’ve resisted putting affiliate links in Advisorator because I’m wary of how it can warp incentives. Too often, I’ll see websites push mediocre products or dubious deals just for the sake of a sales commission, or I’ll wonder if a YouTuber’s glowing product review was motivated more by affiliate revenue than the product’s actual merits. Folks who support Advisorator with paid subscriptions deserve not to worry about biased recommendations.
That said, I’m now rethinking my approach to affiliate links for a few reasons:
- More than 8,500 people now read Advisorator’s free edition, and it’d be nice to get support from those who don’t become paid subscribers.
- Earnings from affiliate fees would allow me to grow the newsletter and spend more time working on it.
- I think there’s a way for me to do affiliate links that doesn’t feel like a huge moral compromise.
Basically, I’m envisioning an approach similar to what I’ve been doing in Cord Cutter Weekly over the past year: I’ll only include affiliate links in the deals section (“Spend Wisely”) toward the end of the newsletter, with a prominent disclosure at the top of the section:
“This part of the newsletter has some affiliate links, which earn me a commission if you wind up buying or subscribing to something.“
Linking to good deals is the entire point of the Spend Wisely section, so having affiliate links shouldn’t change my approach. Just like with Cord Cutter Weekly, I’ll continue to recommend the best deals I can find each week, regardless of whether there’s a sales commission attached. And by limiting affiliate links to this one section, I’ll avoid the urge to tailor more of the newsletter toward selling you stuff.
My plan is to do this for both the free and paid versions of Advisorator. While I could potentially exclude affiliate links from the paid version, that would create extra work without changing any actual content, since the deal list would be the same in both newsletters.
To be clear, I will not include affiliate links in the Deal Alerts that I occasionally send to paid subscribers. Inevitably that would incentivize me to send more emails, and that’s exactly the kind of editorial compromise I’m trying to avoid.
Also: I’m still not doing ads or sponsorships in Advisorator. Figuring out how to get people to click on ads isn’t fun, the potential for conflicts of interest is too high, and I’d rather spend that time and energy on other things.
Unless there’s a strong objection from paid subscribers, I’ll likely start setting up affiliate links within the next few weeks, with clear disclosure and a link back to this post. If you have any feedback in the meantime, please don’t hesitate to send me an email or post your thoughts in the Tech Buds forum.
Thanks again for your support.
-
I’m excited about a menu bar
The more I think on inverting the format for Advisorator’s free edition, the more confident I’m feeling about it, and a lot of that has to do with a menu bar.
Here’s what Advisorator’s top nav bar used to look like:

After some fiddling, here’s what it looks like now:

Most notably, it now has a "Subscribe" link, which leads to the free newsletter sign-up form. This might seem obvious to include, but Advisorator used to be for paying members only, and the website existed only for those subscribers.
It all got kind of awkward as I added and expanded the free edition. The site still catered primarily to paid subscribers, and so I avoided putting a sign-up link in the nav bar so as not to cause confusion. Until now, I’ve also been creating two separate newsletters, and so it made sense to only include the paid edition’s archives in the top nav bar.
The new format will make it much easier for me to have a single, canonical archive, with a paywall that applies to the bottom half (ish) of each newsletter. That means the Archives link will be useful to free and paid subscribers alike.
Meanwhile, I’ve moved the "Home" button over and renamed it to "Membership." When you sign in as a paid subscriber, it serves as a welcome page with quick links to the latest newsletter and other resources. If you’re not a member, you’ll see an explanation of membership benefits and links to subscribe.
All of which helps make way for the aforementioned "Subscribe" button, which gives you an easy way to sign up no matter where you navigate on the site. To me at least, the whole thing feels cleaner, more transparent, and more professional. I hope it leads to more free and paid subscribers alike.
As for The Blog, this is still just a place for me to dump some excess thoughts from my head. I’m not sure that’s worthy of a nav bar item just yet.
-
Fediverse comments: An experiment!
Okay, so in the past week I’ve enabled the following:
- Created a "Blog" section on the Advisorator site.
- Enabled ActivityPub for the blog, so you can follow @blog@advisorator.com to see posts in your feed.
- Connected Obsidian to the blog, so I can publish directly from my favorite note-taking app.
Now it’s time for the next step: Comments!
When I click the publish option here in Obsidian, I’m going to set "Comment Status" to "Open." If all goes to plan, this will allow replies on Mastodon to show up right here on the blog. What could go wrong?
If you’re reading this, hit me with your hottest takes about DOOM, mobile operating systems, or cheese.
-
Flipping Advisorator’s free and paid versions
This might be a bad idea, but I’m going to try inverting the format of Advisorator’s free edition.
Previously, it went like this:
- Quick tip
- An upsell for that week’s feature story, which appears atop the paid newsletter
- News roundup
- A useful app to try, sometimes with an upsell for my ultimate list of awesome apps
- A truncated version of the deal list I usually send out to paid subscribers.
- Another upsell for the paid edition, referencing the omitted deals.
- Sign off.
Now it looks like this:
- The feature story that I used to reserve for paid subscribers
- An upsell for the news, quick tip, useful app, and deal list that now reside only in the paid edition
- Sign off
At minimum, it’s a lot less convoluted, but I’m also hoping it makes the newsletter more enjoyable and shareable for free subscribers. You might be more excited to share, say, an article about an inexpensive AirTag alternative or the best ad blocker than a grab-bag of other stuff. It’s certainly easier for me to share on social media.
At the same time, that grab bag is easier to talk up as a benefit for paid subscribers. They’re not just getting one extra article per week, but rather a whole bundle of useful intel. And that’s in addition to other benefits like my online guides and Slack channel.
If all goes well, this may even allow me to produce one canonical version of the newsletter—and therefore a single archive page—instead of separate free and paid versions. Still, it’s nerve-racking to give away the part of the newsletter that takes maybe 60% of my time each week.
As I mentioned in this week’s issue, we’ll see how it goes and adapt as needed.
